Showing posts with label Montana. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Montana. Show all posts

Monday, May 24, 2010

NEXUS: Quill Physical Presence Test Should Apply to Gross Receipts Taxes

Since National Bellas Hess, Inc. v. Illinois Department of Revenue, 386 U.S. 753 (1967), was decided in 1967, states have attempted to avoid the physical presence test of nexus that the National Bellas Hess case established.  Thus, in the 1980’s, the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue argued that that our client, L. L. Bean, Inc., was required to collect Pennsylvania sales and use tax on all of its sales into the state because the mail order industry had changed since National Bellas Hess was decided.  The Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court squarely rejected this challenge to National Bellas Hess.  L. L. Bean, Inc. v. Department of Revenue, 516 A.2d 820 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1986).

Similarly, the State of California threatened assessment of 300 direct marketers on the ground that they had nexus with California because of their use of 1-800 numbers and acceptance of credit cards.  On behalf of the Direct Marketing Association, Brann & Isaacson sued in federal court, and the Ninth Circuit issued a judgment in favor of the DMA, on behalf of its members, declaring that in the absence of a physical presence in a state, a company is not liable for sales and use tax in that state.  DMA v. Bennett, 916 F.2d 1451 (9th Cir. 1990), cert. denied, 500 U.S. 905 (1991).

The states’ next test case, Quill v. North Dakota, 504 U.S. 298 (1992) (Brann & Isaacson filed an amicus curiae brief on behalf of the DMA in Quill), was yet another unsuccessful effort by the states to overrule and/or limit the physical presence test.

The states’ latest efforts to limit the nexus test under the Commerce Clause by adoption of an economic presence test to measure nexus for gross receipts tax should also be rejected.

Michigan (in the Michigan Business Tax (“MBT”)), Ohio (in the Ohio Commercial Activity Tax (“CAT”), Texas (in the Texas Margin Tax), and Washington (most recently in the May 2010 amendments to its Business and Occupation Tax), however, have asserted that the Quill physical presence test does not apply to gross receipts taxes, but is limited to sales tax.  Citing a footnote in the Quill decision, these states argue for a different standard; namely that the mere economic presence of a taxpayer by sales into the state should create nexus.

The states fail to recognize, however, the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Commonwealth Edison Company, et al. v. State of Montana, 453 U.S. 609, 101 S.Ct. 2946 (1981), which applied a physical presence test to a gross receipts tax.  In that case, the Court addressed the standard to apply to a Montana severance tax on coal extracted from Montana mines, which was a gross receipts tax.  Although the Court upheld the constitutionality of the tax, the Court noted the physical presence standard for determining  nexus.  In particular, the Court cited National Bellas Hess as the standard for finding nexus.  The physical presence test of National Bellas Hess doctrine was confirmed in the Quill case in 1992.

The states’ argument also ignores the fair relation prong of the Complete Auto Transit, Inc. v. Brady, 430 U.S. 274, 279 (1977) test.  The fair relation prong requires that there be a fair relation between a tax and the benefits conferred upon the taxpayer by the State.  Although the Court has not required a detailed accounting of the services the states provide in order to be able to tax, the taxpayer must be engaged in some activity in the state in order to be subject to tax.  Thus, in Oklahoma Tax Commission v. Jefferson Lines, Inc., 514 U.S. 175 (1995), the Court defined the fair relation prong as follows “Complete Auto’s fourth criterion asks only that the measure of the tax be reasonably related to the taxpayer’s presence or activities in the state.” (Id. at 200, citing Commonwealth Edison Company v. Montana as setting forth the applicable standard).  Clearly, if the taxpayer lacks any physical presence in the state, the fair relation prong of Complete Auto cannot be satisfied.

In short, Complete Auto, Commonwealth Edison Company, and Oklahoma Tax Commission provide one basis to resist a state’s gross receipts tax enforcement efforts against online companies and direct marketers that lack a physical presence in the state.

Friday, May 21, 2010

Colorado Enacts Law on Gift Cards; Update on Other States’ Cash Redemption Rules

Amidst the hullaballoo over Colorado’s recently enacted affiliate nexus and out-of-state vendor reporting requirements and its recent economic nexus regulation, Colorado also passed a new law regarding gift cards.

Under the new law, signed by Governor Ritter on April 29, issuers of gift cards, including actual cards and electronic cards, must redeem the remaining value of a gift card for cash if there is $5 or less remaining on the card and the holder of the card so requests. Additionally, sellers may not sell gift cards which contain a service fee, dormancy fee, inactivity fee, maintenance fee, or any other type of fee. The new law does not apply to gift cards which are useable with multiple sellers, unless the multiple sellers are affiliated sellers. Violations of the new statute are deemed deceptive trade practices under Colorado law.

Other states have similar laws and/or pending legislation regarding cash refunds for low balances on gift cards and certificates:

California: Currently permits cash refunds for gift certificates with cash value less than $10. See Cal. Civ. Code § 1749.5(b)(2). California has legislation currently before its Senate that would raise the threshold amount to $20.

Maine: Requires cash refunds for gift and stored value cards with less than $5 remaining on request, except in the case of prepaid telephone cards, cards with an initial value of $5 or less, and cards that were not purchased but were provided as a promotion or as a refund where no receipt was provided. See Me. Rev. Stat. tit. 33, § 1953(1)(G).

Massachusetts: For gift certificates to which value may be added and which have been redeemed in part, the holder of the gift certificate may request the remaining balance be paid in cash once its value falls below $5. For gift certificates prohibiting the holder from adding additional value, the holder can request the balance be paid in cash once 90% of the face value has been redeemed. See Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 200A, § 5D.

Montana: Gift certificates with original values of greater than $5, with less than $5 remaining, must be redeemed for cash on request. See Mont. Code Ann. § 30-14-108(4).

Vermont: If the remaining value of a gift certificate is less than $1.00, the gift certificate is redeemable in cash for its remaining value on demand of the gift certificate’s holder. See Vt. Stat. Ann. tit. 8, § 2704.

Washington: If, after a purchase is made with a gift certificate, the remaining value is less than $5, the gift certificate must be redeemable in cash for its remaining value, on demand of the bearer.  See Wash. Rev. Code § 19.240.020(3).